Entry tags:
An under-considered dilemma
There exists in this world, as far as I know, at least one small community of human beings still entirely isolated from contact with the rest of us. I think they're somewhere in the vicinity of the Amazon. Upon discovering the existence of such a group, the question arises of what to do about them? Should they be contacted, and introduced to the modern world, or left alone, as it is certain that to introduce them to our world would ultimately destroy theirs?
It occurred to me this morning (while reading a book about Hawaiian history) that this is not even the most important consideration, in some ways.
More of a problem would be: to introduce them to our world would probably kill almost all of them.
The net result of introducing people from the Eurasia/Africa set (seriously, world, Europe and Asia are one continent, and separating Africa is dubious; ditto the Americas) to the parts of the world that had been separate from that mass of humanity has been consistently this: they die of assorted plagues. The peoples of Polynesia, Australasia and the Americas weren't the descendents of survivors of smallpox and the like; they had no inherited resistance to it, and the new diseases were devastating.
How could you introduce an isolated people to the modern world without, essentially, murdering them?
It occurred to me this morning (while reading a book about Hawaiian history) that this is not even the most important consideration, in some ways.
More of a problem would be: to introduce them to our world would probably kill almost all of them.
The net result of introducing people from the Eurasia/Africa set (seriously, world, Europe and Asia are one continent, and separating Africa is dubious; ditto the Americas) to the parts of the world that had been separate from that mass of humanity has been consistently this: they die of assorted plagues. The peoples of Polynesia, Australasia and the Americas weren't the descendents of survivors of smallpox and the like; they had no inherited resistance to it, and the new diseases were devastating.
How could you introduce an isolated people to the modern world without, essentially, murdering them?